For teachers
How do we know what animals see?
A free 40-minute lesson for ages 10 and up, built on three of the scenes. No sign-up, no accounts, nothing to install.
At a glance
- Ages: 10 to 14 (grades 5 to 9); works as an opener for high school biology too.
- Time: 40 minutes, or two 20-minute parts.
- You need: one phone, tablet or computer for every 1 to 3 students. A projector helps.
- Privacy: no accounts, no ads, no cookies. The site counts visits (not people); the camera in lens mode never sends a picture anywhere.
- Connects to: NGSS 4-LS1-2 and MS-LS1-8 (senses gather information and send it to the brain), and the practice of evaluating information.
Students will be able to
- Explain that different eyes collect different information: how many kinds of color receptor, how fine a detail, how much light.
- Tell a MEASURED fact from an INFERRED one, and both from a MODELED choice.
- Check a popular claim ("eagles see 8 times sharper") against what was actually measured.
The lesson plan
- 5 minVote. Read three claims aloud and have students vote true or false: "Dogs see in black and white." "Eagles see 8 times sharper than people." "Bees can see colors we can't." Write the votes down; you'll come back to them.
- 15 min
- 10 minCheck the sources. In one scene, each pair taps Sources and finds one claim labeled MEASURED and one labeled MODELED. Ask: why are the animal's colors on screen labeled MODELED? (They are a translation. Nobody knows what an animal experiences.)
- 10 minBack to the votes. Reveal the answers (below), discuss two or three of the questions, then the exit ticket: "One claim I believed that turned out to be wrong, and the number that showed it."
Questions to discuss
- A dog's reds and greens fall together. Why might a red ball be a bad toy for a dog on a lawn? What color would you pick?
- An eagle is about twice as sharp as you in bright light, and at sunset its sharpness drops to about a third of its best. Why would a careful website say "about twice", not "8 times"?
- In the sunscreen study, most of the visitors to the flowers were small wild bees, wasps and flies. What does that let us say about honeybees, and what doesn't it?
- What's the difference between "we found no measurement" and "nobody has ever measured it"?
- Why does the site call its animal colors a "translation"?
Answer key
Each fact below is a claim from that scene's Sources panel, with the same label. The panel gives the paper behind it.
Dog
"Dogs see in black and white": false.
MEASURED A dog has two kinds of color cone where you have three, peaking at about 429 and 555 nm. So reds and greens fall together, but a dog still sees color.
MODELED The dog colors on screen: a published simulation of red-green colorblindness, standing in for a dog's two cones.
Eagle
"Eagles see 8 times sharper": false.
MEASURED A wedge-tailed eagle told stripes apart down to 132 to 143 stripe pairs per degree in bright light. People in the same kind of test: 60. About twice as sharp.
NEEDS SOURCE "4 to 8 times sharper": the site could trace it only to a popular book.
MEASURED At sunset an eagle's sharpness is about a third of its best.
Honeybee
"Bees can see colors we can't": true, with care.
MEASURED A honeybee has three kinds of color receptor, like you, but shifted: they peak at about 344 nm (ultraviolet), 436 nm (blue) and 544 nm (green).
MEASURED Black-eyed Susans misted with sunscreen (which takes away their ultraviolet) drew 5 visits, against 57 for water and 65 for plain air. The visitors were mostly small wild bees, wasps and flies.
MODELED The bee colors on screen: the false-color translation researchers use.
If you have more time
- Lens mode: point a phone at the classroom and switch between a dog's, cat's and jumping spider's eyes. Ask what changes and what doesn't.
- Jumping spider: two kinds of eyes, one blurry all around and one sharp strip it has to aim.
- Your own eye: only a tiny spot of your view is sharp.
Worksheet: how do we know what animals see?
Name: ______________________________ Date: ______________
eyeshineatlas.com · Play each scene with your own eyes first, then look at the animal's view.
| Animal | What I saw with my own eyes | What changed in the animal's view | One number, and its label |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dog | |||
| Eagle | |||
| Honeybee |
Tap Sources in one scene. One claim labeled MEASURED:
One claim labeled MODELED, and why it has that label:
Exit ticket: one claim I believed that turned out to be wrong, and the number that showed it:
Labels: MEASURED = tested in that animal · INFERRED = worked out from measurements · MODELED = the site's own choice · NEEDS SOURCE = no measurement found